Across the last 36 months, DotOutbound users closed just over 50,000 end-user domain sales. We anonymized the dataset, stripped the outliers, and looked for the patterns that separate the deals that close from the ones that stall.
What follows is the short version. The headline: pricing is less important than you think, and timing is more important than almost anyone admits.
The headline numbers
Median closed sale: $4,850. Mean: $11,200 (skewed by a long tail of premium one-word .coms). Median time from first touch to wire: 22 days. Median number of email touches before reply: 2.4.
The single strongest predictor of a closed deal in our dataset wasn't price or domain quality — it was whether the seller responded to the first reply within four hours.
The best day to send
Tuesday is the winner across every region and vertical we sliced. Reply rates on Tuesday outperform Monday by 22%, Friday by 31%, and weekends by more than 60%. The 8:30-10:00 local window beats afternoon sends by 1.6x.
Counterintuitively, the second-best day is Sunday evening — but only for founders and solo operators, not for enterprise contacts.
Reply rates by industry
Fintech and SaaS lead the pack at 13.8% and 12.1% reply rates respectively. E-commerce sits at 9.4%. Healthcare and legal trail at 6.2% — but when they reply, they close at a 2.3x higher rate than the leaders. Different industries reward different patience levels.
- Fintech: 13.8% reply, $7.2k median sale
- SaaS: 12.1% reply, $5.8k median sale
- E-commerce: 9.4% reply, $3.9k median sale
- Healthcare: 6.2% reply, $9.1k median sale
- Legal: 6.2% reply, $11.4k median sale
The language that wins
Messages that referenced a specific company event in the first sentence outperformed generic openers by 2.8x. Messages that mentioned price in the first email underperformed price-free openers by 41%. Messages that asked a question in the closing line outperformed CTAs with a calendar link by 1.5x.
The pattern is consistent: be specific about them, be vague about money, and end with curiosity instead of a transaction.
What stalls deals
Three things kill more deals than any other: slow first responses, switching channels too early (jumping to a phone call before the prospect is ready), and sending price before the prospect asks. If you fix only one, fix the response time.
Priya turns the platform's deal data into the playbooks the team actually uses. Previously a quant at a domain brokerage in Singapore.
Stop waiting for buyers to find you.
DotOutbound surfaces the buyers most likely to want your domain — and helps you start the conversation.
Join the waitlist
